Home / Archives
Archives

The First Challenges Facing the Ukrainian Sea Ports Authority

From the historical archive of Ports of Ukraine, No. 6 (128), 2013. Originally published online on 21 August 2013. Translated from Russian.

On 30 July 2013, Yuriy Vaskov, acting head of the state enterprise Ukrainian Sea Ports Authority (USPA), held a press conference in Odesa at which he told journalists about the new state enterprise.

Since 13 June 2013, Yuriy Vaskov said, the new state enterprise Ukrainian Sea Ports Authority has been performing its principal functions under the Law on Seaports. First, all revenue from port dues, specialised services and other services provided by the Authority began to accrue to USPA.

Second, USPA took over from the commercial seaports the implementation of infrastructure projects launched in previous years. In other words, none of the ongoing port projects was suspended.

Third, we have ensured equal access to port infrastructure for all business entities operating within seaport territories.

I would like to point out at once, Yuriy Vaskov said, that the definition of a seaport changed when the Law on Seaports of Ukraine came into force. Previously, under the Merchant Shipping Code, a seaport was a state enterprise providing port services and constituted a legal entity. Since 13 June, however, a seaport has meant an area of land and water — a geographical concept. Businesses of all types of ownership operate on that land and within those waters, servicing ships, handling cargo and undertaking further processing of goods.

This arrangement is typical of most developed countries. In the port of Antwerp, for example, only 20% of the territory is used for stevedoring activities, while 80% comprises areas where goods undergo further processing. All of this is called a seaport.

That is how things will work here now, too. All employees of stevedoring companies and other entities working within seaport territories are port workers.

Accordingly, unlike the director of the state enterprise who was in charge before 13 June, each seaport now has a head of its port administration (we have 18 such ports). He neither manages nor interferes in the commercial activities of businesses, but coordinates the activities of enterprises of all types of ownership to ensure a unified operating process and equal access to port infrastructure.

USPA has approved a uniform procedure for simple and transparent access to port infrastructure. First, we have set up a hotline based at USPA’s central dispatch office in Odesa. The dispatch office will receive reports of all customer complaints and grievances concerning poor performance, primarily by the administration and, secondly, by other entities operating in the port. We will collect this information, Yuriy Vaskov said, and respond to it.

Second, we have established a single, clear mechanism for concluding contracts with counterparties and providing them with access to strategic port infrastructure — assets carried on USPA’s balance sheet. Let me remind you that these include port waters, hydraulic structures such as berths, breakwaters, dams and channels, and shared facilities such as roads, railway tracks and utility networks where at least two entities use them.

The Authority issued an order giving the head of each seaport three days to conclude agreements with counterparties and introduce a clear procedure for admission to the port, so that the procedure would be uniform everywhere.

Furthermore, the principal purpose of establishing USPA was not so much to centralise the collection and accumulation of port dues as to ensure that they were properly used for their intended purpose: the effective development of strategic assets in seaports. In this connection, Yuriy Vaskov recalled that the Cabinet of Ministers had recently adopted a 25-year Seaport Development Strategy. This is the conceptual and fundamental document for the Authority’s future activities. The Authority is to facilitate the preparation and implementation of a development plan for each seaport.

Councils have now been set up in every seaport. Each council is chaired by the head of the seaport administration and must include the harbour master, as well as any operators of terminals and facilities in the port who wish to join. USPA has asked the seaport councils to draw up development plans for each marine terminal in August, submit the plans to the council and use them as the basis for development plans for each seaport. These will have to be agreed and submitted to the Ministry of Infrastructure for approval. Once the ministry approves them, USPA’s task will be to ensure their implementation.

The Law on Seaports of Ukraine makes it possible to build port facilities using state budget funds, funds earned by USPA or private funds. In the latter case, a private enterprise may either retain ownership of the assets or transfer them to the state, represented by the Sea Ports Authority, and receive compensation through a mechanism now being developed by the Cabinet of Ministers. For each project, we will now have to find the optimal financing model that will allow the project to be implemented as quickly as possible, the acting head of USPA said.

The structure of the Sea Ports Authority has been established. The legal entity is registered in Kyiv at 14 Peremohy Avenue (in the Ministry of Infrastructure building). Its head office is located there as well. It is responsible for centralised accounting, human resources, financial and fixed-asset management, strategy and liaison with government bodies based in Kyiv. It accounts for about 30% of the central staff. The remaining 70% are based in Odesa in the so-called operations office. Their principal functions are coordination, participation in the preparation of seaport development programmes, assistance in implementing them and optimisation of logistics. This also concerns the interfaces between seaports and rail and road carriers, regulatory authorities and other government services.

Where specialists specifically in the maritime and port sector are required, Yuriy Vaskov said, we have concentrated as many of the relevant jobs as possible in Odesa, where such specialists are easier to find.

USPA has 19 branches: 18 seaport administrations and a nineteenth branch, Delta-Pilot. The branches employ specialists responsible for practical technical implementation: development and construction of facilities, maintaining them in proper technical condition, ensuring navigational safety and making effective use of the assets carried on the balance sheet of each of the 19 branches.

In addition, USPA is working on the creation of a Register of Seaports and a Register of Hydraulic Structures, as well as a pilot project to expand the unified Port Community System, which was launched on a trial basis in the port of Odesa. It is hoped that in the autumn it will be possible to move away from paper documents and switch to electronic container clearance.

Responding to journalists’ questions about which enterprises should be included within seaports, Yuriy Vaskov noted that, under the law, all marine terminals, whether or not they adjoin the existing waters of a seaport, must be included within the boundaries of the nearest seaport. Many large private terminals, such as Avlita, TIS, Nika-Tera and Nibulon, have already expressed their wish to become part of the corresponding seaports. They lose nothing as a result. By becoming part of what is defined as a seaport, they gain a number of substantial advantages.

“We are now engaged in a constructive dialogue with all market participants, and I believe that a refusal to become part of a seaport could only be the result of shortcomings on our part in our dialogue with our partners, the private operators.

At the same time, let me reiterate that the law contains a mandatory provision requiring all marine terminals to be included within seaports. The only exceptions are fishing ports.”

Looking ahead, Yuriy Vaskov said, we will very soon raise the question of granting seaports special economic zone status. I think that by the end of this year we will already be proposing the adoption of the relevant regulations.

Asked whether private terminals could receive port dues, Yuriy Vaskov replied that terminals which had built their own berths were entitled to collect berth dues. Under the law, USPA receives ship dues as the user of port waters. But the law also introduced the concept of operational waters. If a private terminal has established operational waters of its own, it is also entitled to collect ship dues for those waters.

Asked why some USPA branches had become loss-making, Yuriy Vaskov replied that the principal reason was the inclusion in these branches of a considerable number of assets unrelated to the Authority’s core activities, particularly social facilities. This was done by decision of the management to avoid social tensions among employees. If loss-making branches lack funds to pay wages and taxes, they will receive those funds from USPA’s central office. In the longer term, however, consideration will have to be given to divesting non-core assets. In any event, the reform has not worsened the position of ports that were experiencing financial difficulties.

Journalists reminded Yuriy Vaskov of the recent detention of the vessel Alina in a Ukrainian port, where environmental inspectors, contrary to international conventions, demanded samples of segregated ballast water, something that was technically impossible. Could USPA prevent such incidents, which damage the reputation of Ukrainian seaports?

The acting head of USPA recalled that such situations arise irrespective of the wishes of the transport ministry, which tries to respond within the scope of its powers. To resolve the problem, government resolutions would have to be amended. This is not easy, since the agreement of other ministries is required.

How many investors have already expressed an interest in acquiring concessions or leases for marine terminals?

Yuriy Vaskov replied that eight or nine port investment projects were already being prepared. It was very important to test the entire procedure and all its terms on the initial projects in order to avoid becoming bogged down in approvals. At the same time, interest in port capacity is growing. This is demonstrated, in particular, by the development of the Malyi Adzhalyk Estuary, which is attracting major companies. For the time being, however, many of them prefer to find an undeveloped stretch of shore on which to build something. The task is to ensure that the access to the sea they are seeking can be found in seaports with professional staff and developed infrastructure.

Source: archived Russian-language publication.